Asymmetries and Climate Futures

Working with Waters in an Indigenous Australian Settlement

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This paper focuses on a water management project in the remote Aboriginal community of Milingimbi, Northern Australia. Drawing on materials and experiences from two distinct stages of this project, we revisit a policy report and engage in ethnographic storytelling in order to highlight a series of sensing practices associated with water management. In the former, a working symmetry between Yolngu and Western water knowledges is actively sought through the practices of the project. However, in the latter, recurrent asymmetries in the research work continue to appear: a bilingual diagram of water usage is displayed but produces confusion; measuring a water hole for salinity, a member of the scientific team throws in a water meter, while a Yolngu elder prefers the telling of an ancestral story; a collaborative 3-D mapping exercise invites participation from community members but struggles to develop an outcome that differs from existing maps used by scientists and government staff. Focusing on these moments as subtle points of rupture, we suggest that attending to “seeing,” “telling,” and “mapping” in both stages of this water management project offers a way to explore the political work of crafting climate futures and beginning to interrogate differing means for “doing difference” within them.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)786-813
Number of pages28
JournalScience, Technology and Human Values
Volume44
Issue number5
Early online date26 May 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2019

Fingerprint

Water management
asymmetry
climate
water management
water
Drawing (graphics)
Water meters
Water
community
staff
participation
Asymmetry
Climate
Water Management
experience
Yolngu

Cite this

@article{200212548bb244bc9a5b8f43e4a453d2,
title = "Asymmetries and Climate Futures: Working with Waters in an Indigenous Australian Settlement",
abstract = "This paper focuses on a water management project in the remote Aboriginal community of Milingimbi, Northern Australia. Drawing on materials and experiences from two distinct stages of this project, we revisit a policy report and engage in ethnographic storytelling in order to highlight a series of sensing practices associated with water management. In the former, a working symmetry between Yolngu and Western water knowledges is actively sought through the practices of the project. However, in the latter, recurrent asymmetries in the research work continue to appear: a bilingual diagram of water usage is displayed but produces confusion; measuring a water hole for salinity, a member of the scientific team throws in a water meter, while a Yolngu elder prefers the telling of an ancestral story; a collaborative 3-D mapping exercise invites participation from community members but struggles to develop an outcome that differs from existing maps used by scientists and government staff. Focusing on these moments as subtle points of rupture, we suggest that attending to “seeing,” “telling,” and “mapping” in both stages of this water management project offers a way to explore the political work of crafting climate futures and beginning to interrogate differing means for “doing difference” within them.",
keywords = "Science and Technology Studies, Anthropocene, Indigenous Knowledge, Water Management, Yolngu, Climate Futures, Sensing Practices",
author = "Michaela Spencer and Endre Danyi and Yasunori Hayashi",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1177/0162243919852667",
language = "English",
volume = "44",
pages = "786--813",
journal = "Science, Technology and Human Values",
issn = "0162-2439",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "5",

}

Asymmetries and Climate Futures : Working with Waters in an Indigenous Australian Settlement. / Spencer, Michaela; Danyi, Endre; Hayashi, Yasunori.

In: Science, Technology and Human Values, Vol. 44, No. 5, 09.2019, p. 786-813.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Asymmetries and Climate Futures

T2 - Working with Waters in an Indigenous Australian Settlement

AU - Spencer, Michaela

AU - Danyi, Endre

AU - Hayashi, Yasunori

PY - 2019/9

Y1 - 2019/9

N2 - This paper focuses on a water management project in the remote Aboriginal community of Milingimbi, Northern Australia. Drawing on materials and experiences from two distinct stages of this project, we revisit a policy report and engage in ethnographic storytelling in order to highlight a series of sensing practices associated with water management. In the former, a working symmetry between Yolngu and Western water knowledges is actively sought through the practices of the project. However, in the latter, recurrent asymmetries in the research work continue to appear: a bilingual diagram of water usage is displayed but produces confusion; measuring a water hole for salinity, a member of the scientific team throws in a water meter, while a Yolngu elder prefers the telling of an ancestral story; a collaborative 3-D mapping exercise invites participation from community members but struggles to develop an outcome that differs from existing maps used by scientists and government staff. Focusing on these moments as subtle points of rupture, we suggest that attending to “seeing,” “telling,” and “mapping” in both stages of this water management project offers a way to explore the political work of crafting climate futures and beginning to interrogate differing means for “doing difference” within them.

AB - This paper focuses on a water management project in the remote Aboriginal community of Milingimbi, Northern Australia. Drawing on materials and experiences from two distinct stages of this project, we revisit a policy report and engage in ethnographic storytelling in order to highlight a series of sensing practices associated with water management. In the former, a working symmetry between Yolngu and Western water knowledges is actively sought through the practices of the project. However, in the latter, recurrent asymmetries in the research work continue to appear: a bilingual diagram of water usage is displayed but produces confusion; measuring a water hole for salinity, a member of the scientific team throws in a water meter, while a Yolngu elder prefers the telling of an ancestral story; a collaborative 3-D mapping exercise invites participation from community members but struggles to develop an outcome that differs from existing maps used by scientists and government staff. Focusing on these moments as subtle points of rupture, we suggest that attending to “seeing,” “telling,” and “mapping” in both stages of this water management project offers a way to explore the political work of crafting climate futures and beginning to interrogate differing means for “doing difference” within them.

KW - Science and Technology Studies

KW - Anthropocene

KW - Indigenous Knowledge

KW - Water Management

KW - Yolngu

KW - Climate Futures

KW - Sensing Practices

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068595302&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0162243919852667

DO - 10.1177/0162243919852667

M3 - Article

VL - 44

SP - 786

EP - 813

JO - Science, Technology and Human Values

JF - Science, Technology and Human Values

SN - 0162-2439

IS - 5

ER -