Biomechanical evaluation of location and mode of failure in three screw fixations for a comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture model

Brett D. Crist, Ferris M. Pfeiffer, Michael S. Khazzam, Rebecca A. Kueny, Gregory J. Della Rocca, William L. Carson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: Pelvic ring–comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture injuries are rotationally and vertically unstable and have a high rate of failure.

Objective: Our study purpose was to use three-dimensional (3D) optical tracking to detect onset location of bone–implant interface failure and measure the distances and angles between screws and line of applied force for correlation to strength of pelvic fracture fixation techniques.

Methods: 3D relative motion across sacral–rami fractures and screws relative to bone was measured with an optical tracking system. Synthetic pelves were used. Comminuted transforaminal sacral–rami fractures were modelled. Each pelvis was stabilised by either (1) two iliosacral screws in S1, (2) one transsacral screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1 and (3) one trans-alar screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1; groups 4–6 consisted of fixation groups with addition of anterior inferior iliac pelvic external fixator. Eighteen-instrumented pelvic models with right ilium fixed simulate single-leg stance. Load was applied to centre of S1 superior endplate. Five cycles of torque was initially applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred. Five cycles of axial load compression was next applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred, followed by axial loading to catastrophic failure. A Student t test was used to determine significance (p < 0.05).

Results: The model, protocol and 3D optical system have the ability to locate how sub-catastrophic failures initiate. Our results indicate failure of all screw-based constructs is due to localised bone failure (screw pull-in push-out at the ipsilateral ilium–screw interface, not in sacrum); thus, no difference was observed when not supplemented with external fixation.

Conclusion: Inclusion of external fixation improved resistance only to torsional loading. Translational Potential of this Article: Patients with comminuted transforaminal sacral–ipsilateral rami fractures benefit from this fixation.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)102-111
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Orthopaedic Translation
Volume16
Early online date10 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Optical Devices
Fracture Fixation
Pelvis
Bone Screws
Ilium
External Fixators
Sacrum
Weight-Bearing
Torque
Leg
Students
Bone and Bones
Wounds and Injuries
daminozide

Cite this

Crist, Brett D. ; Pfeiffer, Ferris M. ; Khazzam, Michael S. ; Kueny, Rebecca A. ; Della Rocca, Gregory J. ; Carson, William L. / Biomechanical evaluation of location and mode of failure in three screw fixations for a comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture model. In: Journal of Orthopaedic Translation. 2019 ; Vol. 16. pp. 102-111.
@article{d3276b12682042fb819bb67190853006,
title = "Biomechanical evaluation of location and mode of failure in three screw fixations for a comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture model",
abstract = "Background: Pelvic ring–comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture injuries are rotationally and vertically unstable and have a high rate of failure. Objective: Our study purpose was to use three-dimensional (3D) optical tracking to detect onset location of bone–implant interface failure and measure the distances and angles between screws and line of applied force for correlation to strength of pelvic fracture fixation techniques. Methods: 3D relative motion across sacral–rami fractures and screws relative to bone was measured with an optical tracking system. Synthetic pelves were used. Comminuted transforaminal sacral–rami fractures were modelled. Each pelvis was stabilised by either (1) two iliosacral screws in S1, (2) one transsacral screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1 and (3) one trans-alar screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1; groups 4–6 consisted of fixation groups with addition of anterior inferior iliac pelvic external fixator. Eighteen-instrumented pelvic models with right ilium fixed simulate single-leg stance. Load was applied to centre of S1 superior endplate. Five cycles of torque was initially applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred. Five cycles of axial load compression was next applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred, followed by axial loading to catastrophic failure. A Student t test was used to determine significance (p < 0.05). Results: The model, protocol and 3D optical system have the ability to locate how sub-catastrophic failures initiate. Our results indicate failure of all screw-based constructs is due to localised bone failure (screw pull-in push-out at the ipsilateral ilium–screw interface, not in sacrum); thus, no difference was observed when not supplemented with external fixation. Conclusion: Inclusion of external fixation improved resistance only to torsional loading. Translational Potential of this Article: Patients with comminuted transforaminal sacral–ipsilateral rami fractures benefit from this fixation.",
keywords = "bone–implant failure, external fixator, fracture stabilisation, pelvic ring injury, pelvic screws, transforaminal sacral fracture",
author = "Crist, {Brett D.} and Pfeiffer, {Ferris M.} and Khazzam, {Michael S.} and Kueny, {Rebecca A.} and {Della Rocca}, {Gregory J.} and Carson, {William L.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jot.2018.06.005",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "102--111",
journal = "Journal of Orthopaedic Translation",
issn = "2214-031X",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Biomechanical evaluation of location and mode of failure in three screw fixations for a comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture model. / Crist, Brett D.; Pfeiffer, Ferris M.; Khazzam, Michael S.; Kueny, Rebecca A.; Della Rocca, Gregory J.; Carson, William L.

In: Journal of Orthopaedic Translation, Vol. 16, 01.2019, p. 102-111.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Biomechanical evaluation of location and mode of failure in three screw fixations for a comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture model

AU - Crist, Brett D.

AU - Pfeiffer, Ferris M.

AU - Khazzam, Michael S.

AU - Kueny, Rebecca A.

AU - Della Rocca, Gregory J.

AU - Carson, William L.

PY - 2019/1

Y1 - 2019/1

N2 - Background: Pelvic ring–comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture injuries are rotationally and vertically unstable and have a high rate of failure. Objective: Our study purpose was to use three-dimensional (3D) optical tracking to detect onset location of bone–implant interface failure and measure the distances and angles between screws and line of applied force for correlation to strength of pelvic fracture fixation techniques. Methods: 3D relative motion across sacral–rami fractures and screws relative to bone was measured with an optical tracking system. Synthetic pelves were used. Comminuted transforaminal sacral–rami fractures were modelled. Each pelvis was stabilised by either (1) two iliosacral screws in S1, (2) one transsacral screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1 and (3) one trans-alar screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1; groups 4–6 consisted of fixation groups with addition of anterior inferior iliac pelvic external fixator. Eighteen-instrumented pelvic models with right ilium fixed simulate single-leg stance. Load was applied to centre of S1 superior endplate. Five cycles of torque was initially applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred. Five cycles of axial load compression was next applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred, followed by axial loading to catastrophic failure. A Student t test was used to determine significance (p < 0.05). Results: The model, protocol and 3D optical system have the ability to locate how sub-catastrophic failures initiate. Our results indicate failure of all screw-based constructs is due to localised bone failure (screw pull-in push-out at the ipsilateral ilium–screw interface, not in sacrum); thus, no difference was observed when not supplemented with external fixation. Conclusion: Inclusion of external fixation improved resistance only to torsional loading. Translational Potential of this Article: Patients with comminuted transforaminal sacral–ipsilateral rami fractures benefit from this fixation.

AB - Background: Pelvic ring–comminuted transforaminal sacral fracture injuries are rotationally and vertically unstable and have a high rate of failure. Objective: Our study purpose was to use three-dimensional (3D) optical tracking to detect onset location of bone–implant interface failure and measure the distances and angles between screws and line of applied force for correlation to strength of pelvic fracture fixation techniques. Methods: 3D relative motion across sacral–rami fractures and screws relative to bone was measured with an optical tracking system. Synthetic pelves were used. Comminuted transforaminal sacral–rami fractures were modelled. Each pelvis was stabilised by either (1) two iliosacral screws in S1, (2) one transsacral screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1 and (3) one trans-alar screw in S1 and one iliosacral screw in S1; groups 4–6 consisted of fixation groups with addition of anterior inferior iliac pelvic external fixator. Eighteen-instrumented pelvic models with right ilium fixed simulate single-leg stance. Load was applied to centre of S1 superior endplate. Five cycles of torque was initially applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred. Five cycles of axial load compression was next applied, sequentially increased until permanent deformation occurred, followed by axial loading to catastrophic failure. A Student t test was used to determine significance (p < 0.05). Results: The model, protocol and 3D optical system have the ability to locate how sub-catastrophic failures initiate. Our results indicate failure of all screw-based constructs is due to localised bone failure (screw pull-in push-out at the ipsilateral ilium–screw interface, not in sacrum); thus, no difference was observed when not supplemented with external fixation. Conclusion: Inclusion of external fixation improved resistance only to torsional loading. Translational Potential of this Article: Patients with comminuted transforaminal sacral–ipsilateral rami fractures benefit from this fixation.

KW - bone–implant failure

KW - external fixator

KW - fracture stabilisation

KW - pelvic ring injury

KW - pelvic screws

KW - transforaminal sacral fracture

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85050084630&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jot.2018.06.005

DO - 10.1016/j.jot.2018.06.005

M3 - Article

VL - 16

SP - 102

EP - 111

JO - Journal of Orthopaedic Translation

JF - Journal of Orthopaedic Translation

SN - 2214-031X

ER -