Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis?

Braden Manns, John W.M. Agar, Mohan Biyani, Peter G. Blake, Alan Cass, Bruce Culleton, Werner Kleophas, Paul Komenda, Thierry Lobbedez, Jennifer MacRae, Mark R. Marshall, Nairne Scott-Douglas, Vikas Srivastava, Peter Magner

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    There are advantages to home dialysis for patients, and kidney care programs, but use remains low in most countries. Health-care policy-makers have many levers to increase use of home dialysis, one of them being economic incentives. These include how health-care funding is provided to kidney care programs and dialysis facilities; how physicians are remunerated for care of home dialysis patients; and financial incentives-or removal of disincentives-for home dialysis patients. This report is based on a comprehensive literature review summarizing the impact of economic incentives for home dialysis and a workshop that brought together an international group of policy-makers, health economists and home dialysis experts to discuss how economic incentives (or removal of economic disincentives) might be used to increase the use of home dialysis. The results of the literature review and the consensus of workshop participants were that financial incentives to dialysis facilities for home dialysis (for instance, through activity-based funding), particularly in for-profit systems, could lead to a small increase in use of home dialysis. The evidence was less clear on the impact of economic incentives for nephrologists, and participants felt this was less important than a nephrologist workforce in support of home dialysis. Workshop participants felt that patient-borne costs experienced by home dialysis patients were unjust and inequitable, though participants noted that there was no evidence that decreasing patient-borne costs would increase use of home dialysis, even among low-income patients. The use of financial incentives for home dialysis-whether directed at dialysis facilities, nephrologists or patients-is only one part of a high-performing system that seeks to increase use of home dialysis.
    Original languageEnglish
    Article numbergfy223
    Pages (from-to)731-741
    Number of pages11
    JournalNephrology Dialysis Transplantation
    Volume34
    Issue number5
    Early online date13 Jul 2018
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2019

    Fingerprint

    Motivation
    Dialysis
    Economics
    Administrative Personnel
    Consensus Development Conferences
    Delivery of Health Care
    Kidney
    Education
    Costs and Cost Analysis
    Home Care Services
    Health Policy
    Patient Care

    Cite this

    Manns, B., Agar, J. W. M., Biyani, M., Blake, P. G., Cass, A., Culleton, B., ... Magner, P. (2019). Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis? Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 34(5), 731-741. [gfy223]. https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfy223
    Manns, Braden ; Agar, John W.M. ; Biyani, Mohan ; Blake, Peter G. ; Cass, Alan ; Culleton, Bruce ; Kleophas, Werner ; Komenda, Paul ; Lobbedez, Thierry ; MacRae, Jennifer ; Marshall, Mark R. ; Scott-Douglas, Nairne ; Srivastava, Vikas ; Magner, Peter. / Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis?. In: Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. 2019 ; Vol. 34, No. 5. pp. 731-741.
    @article{27cf54d7ed2242acad7038185c61808e,
    title = "Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis?",
    abstract = "There are advantages to home dialysis for patients, and kidney care programs, but use remains low in most countries. Health-care policy-makers have many levers to increase use of home dialysis, one of them being economic incentives. These include how health-care funding is provided to kidney care programs and dialysis facilities; how physicians are remunerated for care of home dialysis patients; and financial incentives-or removal of disincentives-for home dialysis patients. This report is based on a comprehensive literature review summarizing the impact of economic incentives for home dialysis and a workshop that brought together an international group of policy-makers, health economists and home dialysis experts to discuss how economic incentives (or removal of economic disincentives) might be used to increase the use of home dialysis. The results of the literature review and the consensus of workshop participants were that financial incentives to dialysis facilities for home dialysis (for instance, through activity-based funding), particularly in for-profit systems, could lead to a small increase in use of home dialysis. The evidence was less clear on the impact of economic incentives for nephrologists, and participants felt this was less important than a nephrologist workforce in support of home dialysis. Workshop participants felt that patient-borne costs experienced by home dialysis patients were unjust and inequitable, though participants noted that there was no evidence that decreasing patient-borne costs would increase use of home dialysis, even among low-income patients. The use of financial incentives for home dialysis-whether directed at dialysis facilities, nephrologists or patients-is only one part of a high-performing system that seeks to increase use of home dialysis.",
    keywords = "dialysis, financial incentives, home dialysis, patients, review",
    author = "Braden Manns and Agar, {John W.M.} and Mohan Biyani and Blake, {Peter G.} and Alan Cass and Bruce Culleton and Werner Kleophas and Paul Komenda and Thierry Lobbedez and Jennifer MacRae and Marshall, {Mark R.} and Nairne Scott-Douglas and Vikas Srivastava and Peter Magner",
    year = "2019",
    month = "5",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1093/ndt/gfy223",
    language = "English",
    volume = "34",
    pages = "731--741",
    journal = "Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation",
    issn = "0931-0509",
    publisher = "Oxford University Press",
    number = "5",

    }

    Manns, B, Agar, JWM, Biyani, M, Blake, PG, Cass, A, Culleton, B, Kleophas, W, Komenda, P, Lobbedez, T, MacRae, J, Marshall, MR, Scott-Douglas, N, Srivastava, V & Magner, P 2019, 'Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis?', Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, vol. 34, no. 5, gfy223, pp. 731-741. https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfy223

    Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis? / Manns, Braden; Agar, John W.M.; Biyani, Mohan; Blake, Peter G.; Cass, Alan; Culleton, Bruce; Kleophas, Werner; Komenda, Paul; Lobbedez, Thierry; MacRae, Jennifer; Marshall, Mark R.; Scott-Douglas, Nairne; Srivastava, Vikas; Magner, Peter.

    In: Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, Vol. 34, No. 5, gfy223, 01.05.2019, p. 731-741.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis?

    AU - Manns, Braden

    AU - Agar, John W.M.

    AU - Biyani, Mohan

    AU - Blake, Peter G.

    AU - Cass, Alan

    AU - Culleton, Bruce

    AU - Kleophas, Werner

    AU - Komenda, Paul

    AU - Lobbedez, Thierry

    AU - MacRae, Jennifer

    AU - Marshall, Mark R.

    AU - Scott-Douglas, Nairne

    AU - Srivastava, Vikas

    AU - Magner, Peter

    PY - 2019/5/1

    Y1 - 2019/5/1

    N2 - There are advantages to home dialysis for patients, and kidney care programs, but use remains low in most countries. Health-care policy-makers have many levers to increase use of home dialysis, one of them being economic incentives. These include how health-care funding is provided to kidney care programs and dialysis facilities; how physicians are remunerated for care of home dialysis patients; and financial incentives-or removal of disincentives-for home dialysis patients. This report is based on a comprehensive literature review summarizing the impact of economic incentives for home dialysis and a workshop that brought together an international group of policy-makers, health economists and home dialysis experts to discuss how economic incentives (or removal of economic disincentives) might be used to increase the use of home dialysis. The results of the literature review and the consensus of workshop participants were that financial incentives to dialysis facilities for home dialysis (for instance, through activity-based funding), particularly in for-profit systems, could lead to a small increase in use of home dialysis. The evidence was less clear on the impact of economic incentives for nephrologists, and participants felt this was less important than a nephrologist workforce in support of home dialysis. Workshop participants felt that patient-borne costs experienced by home dialysis patients were unjust and inequitable, though participants noted that there was no evidence that decreasing patient-borne costs would increase use of home dialysis, even among low-income patients. The use of financial incentives for home dialysis-whether directed at dialysis facilities, nephrologists or patients-is only one part of a high-performing system that seeks to increase use of home dialysis.

    AB - There are advantages to home dialysis for patients, and kidney care programs, but use remains low in most countries. Health-care policy-makers have many levers to increase use of home dialysis, one of them being economic incentives. These include how health-care funding is provided to kidney care programs and dialysis facilities; how physicians are remunerated for care of home dialysis patients; and financial incentives-or removal of disincentives-for home dialysis patients. This report is based on a comprehensive literature review summarizing the impact of economic incentives for home dialysis and a workshop that brought together an international group of policy-makers, health economists and home dialysis experts to discuss how economic incentives (or removal of economic disincentives) might be used to increase the use of home dialysis. The results of the literature review and the consensus of workshop participants were that financial incentives to dialysis facilities for home dialysis (for instance, through activity-based funding), particularly in for-profit systems, could lead to a small increase in use of home dialysis. The evidence was less clear on the impact of economic incentives for nephrologists, and participants felt this was less important than a nephrologist workforce in support of home dialysis. Workshop participants felt that patient-borne costs experienced by home dialysis patients were unjust and inequitable, though participants noted that there was no evidence that decreasing patient-borne costs would increase use of home dialysis, even among low-income patients. The use of financial incentives for home dialysis-whether directed at dialysis facilities, nephrologists or patients-is only one part of a high-performing system that seeks to increase use of home dialysis.

    KW - dialysis

    KW - financial incentives

    KW - home dialysis

    KW - patients

    KW - review

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85057992242&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1093/ndt/gfy223

    DO - 10.1093/ndt/gfy223

    M3 - Article

    VL - 34

    SP - 731

    EP - 741

    JO - Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation

    JF - Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation

    SN - 0931-0509

    IS - 5

    M1 - gfy223

    ER -

    Manns B, Agar JWM, Biyani M, Blake PG, Cass A, Culleton B et al. Can economic incentives increase the use of home dialysis? Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation. 2019 May 1;34(5):731-741. gfy223. https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfy223