Contemporary Aboriginal settlements

Understanding mixed-market approaches

Judith Lovell, Don Zoellner, John Guenther, François Brouard, J.J. McMurtry

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

    11 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    As the authors in Chapter 7 of this volume have expounded, contemporary public policy making is often based upon the use of data and statistics provided by national agencies through collections such as censuses. These are not altogether ‘fit for purpose’ in relation to the small resident numbers living in contemporary Aboriginal settlements in remote regions of advanced market democracies. On the one hand, the laws of large numbers underpin the power of the data and statistics approach, and quite rationally, policy is made on the basis of understanding what happens at the population level. On the other hand, the economically rational individual choice maker is the conceptual unit by which economic activity is understood by policy makers. Because most public policy is aimed at changing behaviour (Australian Public Service Commission, 2007) the actions of individuals are guided by a series of encouragements and penalties to assist in decision- aking. Results are measured and reported upon at the popum lation level. This produces a paradox – the targets of policies are at the personal level while the understanding of their activities is at the population level. Foucault (2007, pp. 127–9) refers to this as ‘individualising yet totalising’ and a feature of modern government which produces constant tension in the implementation of programmes and policies, articularly p among settlements ‘on the edge’ of developed nations (Carson et al., 2011). It is ironic that it was the application of...
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationSettlements at the Edge Remote
    Subtitle of host publicationHuman Settlements in Developed Nations
    EditorsAndrew Taylor, Dean B. Carson, Prescott C. Ensign, Lee Huskey, Rasmus O. Rasmussen, Gertrude Saxinger
    Place of PublicationCheltenham, UK
    PublisherEdward Elgar Publishing
    Chapter11
    Pages246-269
    Number of pages24
    ISBN (Electronic)9781784711962
    ISBN (Print)9781784711955
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 30 Sep 2016

    Fingerprint

    demographic situation
    public policy
    statistics
    market
    public service
    penalty
    census
    resident
    democracy
    Law
    economics

    Cite this

    Lovell, J., Zoellner, D., Guenther, J., Brouard, F., & McMurtry, J. J. (2016). Contemporary Aboriginal settlements: Understanding mixed-market approaches. In A. Taylor, D. B. Carson, P. C. Ensign, L. Huskey, R. O. Rasmussen, & G. Saxinger (Eds.), Settlements at the Edge Remote : Human Settlements in Developed Nations (pp. 246-269). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711962.00019
    Lovell, Judith ; Zoellner, Don ; Guenther, John ; Brouard, François ; McMurtry, J.J. / Contemporary Aboriginal settlements : Understanding mixed-market approaches. Settlements at the Edge Remote : Human Settlements in Developed Nations. editor / Andrew Taylor ; Dean B. Carson ; Prescott C. Ensign ; Lee Huskey ; Rasmus O. Rasmussen ; Gertrude Saxinger. Cheltenham, UK : Edward Elgar Publishing, 2016. pp. 246-269
    @inbook{97c95378e0b5448ea63a8e96389c1709,
    title = "Contemporary Aboriginal settlements: Understanding mixed-market approaches",
    abstract = "As the authors in Chapter 7 of this volume have expounded, contemporary public policy making is often based upon the use of data and statistics provided by national agencies through collections such as censuses. These are not altogether ‘fit for purpose’ in relation to the small resident numbers living in contemporary Aboriginal settlements in remote regions of advanced market democracies. On the one hand, the laws of large numbers underpin the power of the data and statistics approach, and quite rationally, policy is made on the basis of understanding what happens at the population level. On the other hand, the economically rational individual choice maker is the conceptual unit by which economic activity is understood by policy makers. Because most public policy is aimed at changing behaviour (Australian Public Service Commission, 2007) the actions of individuals are guided by a series of encouragements and penalties to assist in decision- aking. Results are measured and reported upon at the popum lation level. This produces a paradox – the targets of policies are at the personal level while the understanding of their activities is at the population level. Foucault (2007, pp. 127–9) refers to this as ‘individualising yet totalising’ and a feature of modern government which produces constant tension in the implementation of programmes and policies, articularly p among settlements ‘on the edge’ of developed nations (Carson et al., 2011). It is ironic that it was the application of...",
    author = "Judith Lovell and Don Zoellner and John Guenther and Fran{\cc}ois Brouard and J.J. McMurtry",
    year = "2016",
    month = "9",
    day = "30",
    doi = "10.4337/9781784711962.00019",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "9781784711955",
    pages = "246--269",
    editor = "Taylor, {Andrew } and Carson, {Dean B. } and Ensign, {Prescott C. } and Huskey, {Lee } and Rasmussen, {Rasmus O. } and Saxinger, {Gertrude }",
    booktitle = "Settlements at the Edge Remote",
    publisher = "Edward Elgar Publishing",
    address = "United Kingdom",

    }

    Lovell, J, Zoellner, D, Guenther, J, Brouard, F & McMurtry, JJ 2016, Contemporary Aboriginal settlements: Understanding mixed-market approaches. in A Taylor, DB Carson, PC Ensign, L Huskey, RO Rasmussen & G Saxinger (eds), Settlements at the Edge Remote : Human Settlements in Developed Nations. Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, UK, pp. 246-269. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711962.00019

    Contemporary Aboriginal settlements : Understanding mixed-market approaches. / Lovell, Judith; Zoellner, Don; Guenther, John; Brouard, François; McMurtry, J.J.

    Settlements at the Edge Remote : Human Settlements in Developed Nations. ed. / Andrew Taylor; Dean B. Carson; Prescott C. Ensign; Lee Huskey; Rasmus O. Rasmussen; Gertrude Saxinger. Cheltenham, UK : Edward Elgar Publishing, 2016. p. 246-269.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - Contemporary Aboriginal settlements

    T2 - Understanding mixed-market approaches

    AU - Lovell, Judith

    AU - Zoellner, Don

    AU - Guenther, John

    AU - Brouard, François

    AU - McMurtry, J.J.

    PY - 2016/9/30

    Y1 - 2016/9/30

    N2 - As the authors in Chapter 7 of this volume have expounded, contemporary public policy making is often based upon the use of data and statistics provided by national agencies through collections such as censuses. These are not altogether ‘fit for purpose’ in relation to the small resident numbers living in contemporary Aboriginal settlements in remote regions of advanced market democracies. On the one hand, the laws of large numbers underpin the power of the data and statistics approach, and quite rationally, policy is made on the basis of understanding what happens at the population level. On the other hand, the economically rational individual choice maker is the conceptual unit by which economic activity is understood by policy makers. Because most public policy is aimed at changing behaviour (Australian Public Service Commission, 2007) the actions of individuals are guided by a series of encouragements and penalties to assist in decision- aking. Results are measured and reported upon at the popum lation level. This produces a paradox – the targets of policies are at the personal level while the understanding of their activities is at the population level. Foucault (2007, pp. 127–9) refers to this as ‘individualising yet totalising’ and a feature of modern government which produces constant tension in the implementation of programmes and policies, articularly p among settlements ‘on the edge’ of developed nations (Carson et al., 2011). It is ironic that it was the application of...

    AB - As the authors in Chapter 7 of this volume have expounded, contemporary public policy making is often based upon the use of data and statistics provided by national agencies through collections such as censuses. These are not altogether ‘fit for purpose’ in relation to the small resident numbers living in contemporary Aboriginal settlements in remote regions of advanced market democracies. On the one hand, the laws of large numbers underpin the power of the data and statistics approach, and quite rationally, policy is made on the basis of understanding what happens at the population level. On the other hand, the economically rational individual choice maker is the conceptual unit by which economic activity is understood by policy makers. Because most public policy is aimed at changing behaviour (Australian Public Service Commission, 2007) the actions of individuals are guided by a series of encouragements and penalties to assist in decision- aking. Results are measured and reported upon at the popum lation level. This produces a paradox – the targets of policies are at the personal level while the understanding of their activities is at the population level. Foucault (2007, pp. 127–9) refers to this as ‘individualising yet totalising’ and a feature of modern government which produces constant tension in the implementation of programmes and policies, articularly p among settlements ‘on the edge’ of developed nations (Carson et al., 2011). It is ironic that it was the application of...

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85016339522&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.4337/9781784711962.00019

    DO - 10.4337/9781784711962.00019

    M3 - Chapter

    SN - 9781784711955

    SP - 246

    EP - 269

    BT - Settlements at the Edge Remote

    A2 - Taylor, Andrew

    A2 - Carson, Dean B.

    A2 - Ensign, Prescott C.

    A2 - Huskey, Lee

    A2 - Rasmussen, Rasmus O.

    A2 - Saxinger, Gertrude

    PB - Edward Elgar Publishing

    CY - Cheltenham, UK

    ER -

    Lovell J, Zoellner D, Guenther J, Brouard F, McMurtry JJ. Contemporary Aboriginal settlements: Understanding mixed-market approaches. In Taylor A, Carson DB, Ensign PC, Huskey L, Rasmussen RO, Saxinger G, editors, Settlements at the Edge Remote : Human Settlements in Developed Nations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. 2016. p. 246-269 https://doi.org/10.4337/9781784711962.00019