Health reporting system in two subdistricts in Eastern Indonesia

Highlighting the role of village midwifes

Frederika Ngana, Bronwyn Myers, Suzanne Belton

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    Objective: to describe the system of health reporting by village midwives and two rural clinics in eastern Indonesia and solve some of the problems in this system through consultation.

    Design: participatory action research model where problems are identified by those most affected and solutions sought. Clinic staff were observed and interviewed regarding their work roles and reporting duties. Allocation of work time to various tasks was recorded by all clinic staff before and after the implementation of a new health recording system. Several information sessions and focus group discussions were held with village midwives and other health staff to identify and address problems.

    Setting: 
    Indonesia initiated a programme in 1989, aiming to place a midwife in every village, in response to high maternal mortality rates and low rates of births attended by trained birth assistants. Remote rural villages in eastern Indonesia have difficulty recruiting and retaining village midwives. These midwives play a crucial role in health reporting. During 2010 a new system of recording and reporting by clinics was implemented.

    Participants: 
    village and clinic health staff in two rural subdistricts in eastern Indonesia.

    Findings: 
    there was incomplete coverage by village midwives in the two subdistricts studied; 28% of villages had a resident midwife, 48% had a visiting midwife and 24% had only monthly visits by a mobile clinic. Village midwives performed duties additional to their official duties and training. Village midwives had problems associated with the reporting system including inconsistency in reporting, poor access to individual patient histories and poor access to clinics. These problems resulted in incompleteness and poor timeliness of data transfer.

    Key conclusions: 
    midwives in remote villages felt compelled to provide services for which they were not trained. Poor quality of data reporting resulted from inconsistent reporting methods. Local staff can successfully change and manage reporting systems if given appropriate support and training.

    Implications for practice: 
    socialisation of health reporting systems among all staff involved can lead to improved data consistency and completeness. Effective systems for data transfer and reporting may reduce time spent on these tasks by some staff. Improvements to accuracy of data and availability of individual patient histories have the potential to contribute to improved health care. Quality of health care by village midwives should be addressed by adequate training and improved transport.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)809-815
    Number of pages7
    JournalMidwifery
    Volume28
    Issue number6
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Dec 2012

    Fingerprint

    Indonesia
    Midwifery
    Health
    Research Design
    Mobile Health Units
    Training Support
    Socialization
    Maternal Mortality
    Quality of Health Care
    Birth Rate
    Health Services Research
    Focus Groups
    Referral and Consultation
    Parturition

    Cite this

    Ngana, Frederika ; Myers, Bronwyn ; Belton, Suzanne. / Health reporting system in two subdistricts in Eastern Indonesia : Highlighting the role of village midwifes. In: Midwifery. 2012 ; Vol. 28, No. 6. pp. 809-815.
    @article{33e4402c79e7419b9a42f4cab46ff6a9,
    title = "Health reporting system in two subdistricts in Eastern Indonesia: Highlighting the role of village midwifes",
    abstract = "Objective: to describe the system of health reporting by village midwives and two rural clinics in eastern Indonesia and solve some of the problems in this system through consultation.Design: participatory action research model where problems are identified by those most affected and solutions sought. Clinic staff were observed and interviewed regarding their work roles and reporting duties. Allocation of work time to various tasks was recorded by all clinic staff before and after the implementation of a new health recording system. Several information sessions and focus group discussions were held with village midwives and other health staff to identify and address problems.Setting: Indonesia initiated a programme in 1989, aiming to place a midwife in every village, in response to high maternal mortality rates and low rates of births attended by trained birth assistants. Remote rural villages in eastern Indonesia have difficulty recruiting and retaining village midwives. These midwives play a crucial role in health reporting. During 2010 a new system of recording and reporting by clinics was implemented.Participants: village and clinic health staff in two rural subdistricts in eastern Indonesia.Findings: there was incomplete coverage by village midwives in the two subdistricts studied; 28{\%} of villages had a resident midwife, 48{\%} had a visiting midwife and 24{\%} had only monthly visits by a mobile clinic. Village midwives performed duties additional to their official duties and training. Village midwives had problems associated with the reporting system including inconsistency in reporting, poor access to individual patient histories and poor access to clinics. These problems resulted in incompleteness and poor timeliness of data transfer.Key conclusions: midwives in remote villages felt compelled to provide services for which they were not trained. Poor quality of data reporting resulted from inconsistent reporting methods. Local staff can successfully change and manage reporting systems if given appropriate support and training.Implications for practice: socialisation of health reporting systems among all staff involved can lead to improved data consistency and completeness. Effective systems for data transfer and reporting may reduce time spent on these tasks by some staff. Improvements to accuracy of data and availability of individual patient histories have the potential to contribute to improved health care. Quality of health care by village midwives should be addressed by adequate training and improved transport.",
    keywords = "adult, article, female, health care delivery, health care planning, health service, health survey, human, Indonesia, methodology, midwife, organization and management, pregnancy, pregnancy complication, prenatal care, rural health care, statistics, young adult, Adult, Female, Health Services Accessibility, Humans, Maternal Health Services, Medically Underserved Area, Midwifery, Population Surveillance, Pregnancy, Pregnancy Complications, Prenatal Care, Rural Health Services, Young Adult",
    author = "Frederika Ngana and Bronwyn Myers and Suzanne Belton",
    year = "2012",
    month = "12",
    doi = "10.1016/j.midw.2011.09.005",
    language = "English",
    volume = "28",
    pages = "809--815",
    journal = "Midwifery",
    issn = "0266-6138",
    publisher = "Churchill Livingstone",
    number = "6",

    }

    Health reporting system in two subdistricts in Eastern Indonesia : Highlighting the role of village midwifes. / Ngana, Frederika; Myers, Bronwyn; Belton, Suzanne.

    In: Midwifery, Vol. 28, No. 6, 12.2012, p. 809-815.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Health reporting system in two subdistricts in Eastern Indonesia

    T2 - Highlighting the role of village midwifes

    AU - Ngana, Frederika

    AU - Myers, Bronwyn

    AU - Belton, Suzanne

    PY - 2012/12

    Y1 - 2012/12

    N2 - Objective: to describe the system of health reporting by village midwives and two rural clinics in eastern Indonesia and solve some of the problems in this system through consultation.Design: participatory action research model where problems are identified by those most affected and solutions sought. Clinic staff were observed and interviewed regarding their work roles and reporting duties. Allocation of work time to various tasks was recorded by all clinic staff before and after the implementation of a new health recording system. Several information sessions and focus group discussions were held with village midwives and other health staff to identify and address problems.Setting: Indonesia initiated a programme in 1989, aiming to place a midwife in every village, in response to high maternal mortality rates and low rates of births attended by trained birth assistants. Remote rural villages in eastern Indonesia have difficulty recruiting and retaining village midwives. These midwives play a crucial role in health reporting. During 2010 a new system of recording and reporting by clinics was implemented.Participants: village and clinic health staff in two rural subdistricts in eastern Indonesia.Findings: there was incomplete coverage by village midwives in the two subdistricts studied; 28% of villages had a resident midwife, 48% had a visiting midwife and 24% had only monthly visits by a mobile clinic. Village midwives performed duties additional to their official duties and training. Village midwives had problems associated with the reporting system including inconsistency in reporting, poor access to individual patient histories and poor access to clinics. These problems resulted in incompleteness and poor timeliness of data transfer.Key conclusions: midwives in remote villages felt compelled to provide services for which they were not trained. Poor quality of data reporting resulted from inconsistent reporting methods. Local staff can successfully change and manage reporting systems if given appropriate support and training.Implications for practice: socialisation of health reporting systems among all staff involved can lead to improved data consistency and completeness. Effective systems for data transfer and reporting may reduce time spent on these tasks by some staff. Improvements to accuracy of data and availability of individual patient histories have the potential to contribute to improved health care. Quality of health care by village midwives should be addressed by adequate training and improved transport.

    AB - Objective: to describe the system of health reporting by village midwives and two rural clinics in eastern Indonesia and solve some of the problems in this system through consultation.Design: participatory action research model where problems are identified by those most affected and solutions sought. Clinic staff were observed and interviewed regarding their work roles and reporting duties. Allocation of work time to various tasks was recorded by all clinic staff before and after the implementation of a new health recording system. Several information sessions and focus group discussions were held with village midwives and other health staff to identify and address problems.Setting: Indonesia initiated a programme in 1989, aiming to place a midwife in every village, in response to high maternal mortality rates and low rates of births attended by trained birth assistants. Remote rural villages in eastern Indonesia have difficulty recruiting and retaining village midwives. These midwives play a crucial role in health reporting. During 2010 a new system of recording and reporting by clinics was implemented.Participants: village and clinic health staff in two rural subdistricts in eastern Indonesia.Findings: there was incomplete coverage by village midwives in the two subdistricts studied; 28% of villages had a resident midwife, 48% had a visiting midwife and 24% had only monthly visits by a mobile clinic. Village midwives performed duties additional to their official duties and training. Village midwives had problems associated with the reporting system including inconsistency in reporting, poor access to individual patient histories and poor access to clinics. These problems resulted in incompleteness and poor timeliness of data transfer.Key conclusions: midwives in remote villages felt compelled to provide services for which they were not trained. Poor quality of data reporting resulted from inconsistent reporting methods. Local staff can successfully change and manage reporting systems if given appropriate support and training.Implications for practice: socialisation of health reporting systems among all staff involved can lead to improved data consistency and completeness. Effective systems for data transfer and reporting may reduce time spent on these tasks by some staff. Improvements to accuracy of data and availability of individual patient histories have the potential to contribute to improved health care. Quality of health care by village midwives should be addressed by adequate training and improved transport.

    KW - adult

    KW - article

    KW - female

    KW - health care delivery

    KW - health care planning

    KW - health service

    KW - health survey

    KW - human

    KW - Indonesia

    KW - methodology

    KW - midwife

    KW - organization and management

    KW - pregnancy

    KW - pregnancy complication

    KW - prenatal care

    KW - rural health care

    KW - statistics

    KW - young adult

    KW - Adult

    KW - Female

    KW - Health Services Accessibility

    KW - Humans

    KW - Maternal Health Services

    KW - Medically Underserved Area

    KW - Midwifery

    KW - Population Surveillance

    KW - Pregnancy

    KW - Pregnancy Complications

    KW - Prenatal Care

    KW - Rural Health Services

    KW - Young Adult

    U2 - 10.1016/j.midw.2011.09.005

    DO - 10.1016/j.midw.2011.09.005

    M3 - Article

    VL - 28

    SP - 809

    EP - 815

    JO - Midwifery

    JF - Midwifery

    SN - 0266-6138

    IS - 6

    ER -