Intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the actiwatch 4 accelerometer in a mechanical laboratory setting

Ashley Routen, Dominic Upton, Martin Edwards, Derek Peters

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This study aimed to quantify the intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the Actiwatch 4 accelerometer (AW4) in a mechanical setting. Twenty seven AW4 were attached to an isokinetic dynamometer and subjected to angular acceleration for 30 min at 50 deg/sec representing moderate intensity (MPA condition) and 200 deg/sec representing vigorous intensity (VPA condition), with a repeat trial conducted. Reliability was assessed using coefficient of variation (CV), absolute percent error (APE), and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Mean AW4 activity counts displayed acceptable reliability according to CV in both conditions (ConMPA: CVintra = 4.6%, APEintra = 6.6%, CVinter = 6.4%, APEinter = 5.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 3.9%, APEintra = 5.6%, CVinter = 5.9%, APEinter = 4.7%). When counts were re-categorised into minutes of MPA and VPA, lower CV values were observed (ConMPA: CVintra = 3.2%, APEintra = 4.5%, CVinter = 4.3%, APEinter = 3.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 0.0%, APEintra = 0.0%, CVinter = 0.0%, APEinter = 0.0%). When activity counts were re-categorised as minutes of MVPA, excellent reliability was observed (CVintra, APEintra, CVinter, and APEinter = 0.0%) in both conditions. Mean AW4 activity counts exhibit reliability statistics comparable to other accelerometers. Reliability is improved when activity counts are re-categorised as time spent in MPA and VPA, with greatest reliability obtained when counts are recategorised as time spent in MVPA. As MVPA is the subcomponent of physical activity most associated with health benefits it would appear that the AW4 is reliable for measuring time spent in this health enhancing intensity category, at least from testing in a mechanical laboratory setting.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)17-24
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Human Kinetics
Volume31
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Insurance Benefits
Health

Cite this

@article{176b607ce83541f9afcc59f1cfc5b24c,
title = "Intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the actiwatch 4 accelerometer in a mechanical laboratory setting",
abstract = "This study aimed to quantify the intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the Actiwatch 4 accelerometer (AW4) in a mechanical setting. Twenty seven AW4 were attached to an isokinetic dynamometer and subjected to angular acceleration for 30 min at 50 deg/sec representing moderate intensity (MPA condition) and 200 deg/sec representing vigorous intensity (VPA condition), with a repeat trial conducted. Reliability was assessed using coefficient of variation (CV), absolute percent error (APE), and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Mean AW4 activity counts displayed acceptable reliability according to CV in both conditions (ConMPA: CVintra = 4.6{\%}, APEintra = 6.6{\%}, CVinter = 6.4{\%}, APEinter = 5.2{\%}; ConVPA: CVintra = 3.9{\%}, APEintra = 5.6{\%}, CVinter = 5.9{\%}, APEinter = 4.7{\%}). When counts were re-categorised into minutes of MPA and VPA, lower CV values were observed (ConMPA: CVintra = 3.2{\%}, APEintra = 4.5{\%}, CVinter = 4.3{\%}, APEinter = 3.2{\%}; ConVPA: CVintra = 0.0{\%}, APEintra = 0.0{\%}, CVinter = 0.0{\%}, APEinter = 0.0{\%}). When activity counts were re-categorised as minutes of MVPA, excellent reliability was observed (CVintra, APEintra, CVinter, and APEinter = 0.0{\%}) in both conditions. Mean AW4 activity counts exhibit reliability statistics comparable to other accelerometers. Reliability is improved when activity counts are re-categorised as time spent in MPA and VPA, with greatest reliability obtained when counts are recategorised as time spent in MVPA. As MVPA is the subcomponent of physical activity most associated with health benefits it would appear that the AW4 is reliable for measuring time spent in this health enhancing intensity category, at least from testing in a mechanical laboratory setting.",
keywords = "Accelerometer, Activity monitor, Measurement, Physical activity, Repeatability",
author = "Ashley Routen and Dominic Upton and Martin Edwards and Derek Peters",
year = "2012",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.2478/v10078-012-0002-z",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "17--24",
journal = "Journal of Human Kinetics",
issn = "1640-5544",
publisher = "Polish Academy of Science, Committee of Physical Culture",
number = "1",

}

Intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the actiwatch 4 accelerometer in a mechanical laboratory setting. / Routen, Ashley; Upton, Dominic; Edwards, Martin; Peters, Derek.

In: Journal of Human Kinetics, Vol. 31, No. 1, 01.03.2012, p. 17-24.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the actiwatch 4 accelerometer in a mechanical laboratory setting

AU - Routen, Ashley

AU - Upton, Dominic

AU - Edwards, Martin

AU - Peters, Derek

PY - 2012/3/1

Y1 - 2012/3/1

N2 - This study aimed to quantify the intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the Actiwatch 4 accelerometer (AW4) in a mechanical setting. Twenty seven AW4 were attached to an isokinetic dynamometer and subjected to angular acceleration for 30 min at 50 deg/sec representing moderate intensity (MPA condition) and 200 deg/sec representing vigorous intensity (VPA condition), with a repeat trial conducted. Reliability was assessed using coefficient of variation (CV), absolute percent error (APE), and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Mean AW4 activity counts displayed acceptable reliability according to CV in both conditions (ConMPA: CVintra = 4.6%, APEintra = 6.6%, CVinter = 6.4%, APEinter = 5.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 3.9%, APEintra = 5.6%, CVinter = 5.9%, APEinter = 4.7%). When counts were re-categorised into minutes of MPA and VPA, lower CV values were observed (ConMPA: CVintra = 3.2%, APEintra = 4.5%, CVinter = 4.3%, APEinter = 3.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 0.0%, APEintra = 0.0%, CVinter = 0.0%, APEinter = 0.0%). When activity counts were re-categorised as minutes of MVPA, excellent reliability was observed (CVintra, APEintra, CVinter, and APEinter = 0.0%) in both conditions. Mean AW4 activity counts exhibit reliability statistics comparable to other accelerometers. Reliability is improved when activity counts are re-categorised as time spent in MPA and VPA, with greatest reliability obtained when counts are recategorised as time spent in MVPA. As MVPA is the subcomponent of physical activity most associated with health benefits it would appear that the AW4 is reliable for measuring time spent in this health enhancing intensity category, at least from testing in a mechanical laboratory setting.

AB - This study aimed to quantify the intra-and inter-instrument reliability of the Actiwatch 4 accelerometer (AW4) in a mechanical setting. Twenty seven AW4 were attached to an isokinetic dynamometer and subjected to angular acceleration for 30 min at 50 deg/sec representing moderate intensity (MPA condition) and 200 deg/sec representing vigorous intensity (VPA condition), with a repeat trial conducted. Reliability was assessed using coefficient of variation (CV), absolute percent error (APE), and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). Mean AW4 activity counts displayed acceptable reliability according to CV in both conditions (ConMPA: CVintra = 4.6%, APEintra = 6.6%, CVinter = 6.4%, APEinter = 5.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 3.9%, APEintra = 5.6%, CVinter = 5.9%, APEinter = 4.7%). When counts were re-categorised into minutes of MPA and VPA, lower CV values were observed (ConMPA: CVintra = 3.2%, APEintra = 4.5%, CVinter = 4.3%, APEinter = 3.2%; ConVPA: CVintra = 0.0%, APEintra = 0.0%, CVinter = 0.0%, APEinter = 0.0%). When activity counts were re-categorised as minutes of MVPA, excellent reliability was observed (CVintra, APEintra, CVinter, and APEinter = 0.0%) in both conditions. Mean AW4 activity counts exhibit reliability statistics comparable to other accelerometers. Reliability is improved when activity counts are re-categorised as time spent in MPA and VPA, with greatest reliability obtained when counts are recategorised as time spent in MVPA. As MVPA is the subcomponent of physical activity most associated with health benefits it would appear that the AW4 is reliable for measuring time spent in this health enhancing intensity category, at least from testing in a mechanical laboratory setting.

KW - Accelerometer

KW - Activity monitor

KW - Measurement

KW - Physical activity

KW - Repeatability

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84859404844&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2478/v10078-012-0002-z

DO - 10.2478/v10078-012-0002-z

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 17

EP - 24

JO - Journal of Human Kinetics

JF - Journal of Human Kinetics

SN - 1640-5544

IS - 1

ER -