Sources and drivers of contamination along an urban tropical river (Ciliwung, Indonesia)

Insights from microbial DNA, isotopes and water chemistry

Clément Duvert, Cindy R. Priadi, Alea M. Rose, Ayik Abdillah, Dwinanti R. Marthanty, Karen S. Gibb, Mirjam Kaestli

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    Wastewater treatment infrastructure is lacking in many developing countries, often resulting in high loads of contaminants discharged to urban rivers. In these countries, targeted pollution mitigation requires an understanding of where, how and when contaminants enter water bodies. Here we report on contamination of the Ciliwung River, a dynamic, tropical system flowing through the Jakarta metropolitan area (Indonesia). We measured a set of isotopic, chemical and microbial tracers in representative water and contamination sources, as well as longitudinally within the river, to assess the spatial and temporal variations in contaminant levels in and pathways to the river. In the dry season, we observed a tight coupling between locally recharged groundwater sources and the river, whereas in the wet season, one single water source originating from the fractured headwaters predominantly contributed to river flow. Yet, the flushing of upstream waters in the wet season did not always lead to the dilution of contaminants downstream. We delineated several contamination hotspots along the river, particularly active during the wet season due to higher hydrological connectivity between sources and the river. These hotspots may originate from septic tank leakage, as supported by metal ratios and dominant microbial communities, although we could not rule out other potential sources such as urban runoff or sediment resuspension. Bayesian source tracking on the whole microbial community proved useful in outlining processes that conventional tracers did not capture, such as the occurrence of a localised domestic contamination in the upper catchment, and the inflow of agricultural runoff all along the river profile during the wet season. Our study emphasises the role of rivers as biogeochemical reactors that constantly process and transform contaminants and microbial communities. We also demonstrate the value of using isotopic, chemical and microbial tools together to trace the movement of water and contaminants through urban rivers.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)382-393
    Number of pages12
    JournalScience of the Total Environment
    Volume682
    Issue numberSeptember
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 10 Sep 2019

    Fingerprint

    Isotopes
    water chemistry
    Contamination
    DNA
    Rivers
    isotope
    Water
    river
    Impurities
    wet season
    pollutant
    microbial community
    tracer
    contamination
    Agricultural runoff
    Septic tanks
    agricultural runoff
    water
    resuspension
    flushing

    Cite this

    @article{a678a7f73bfb4a89b7769f8eb731545c,
    title = "Sources and drivers of contamination along an urban tropical river (Ciliwung, Indonesia): Insights from microbial DNA, isotopes and water chemistry",
    abstract = "Wastewater treatment infrastructure is lacking in many developing countries, often resulting in high loads of contaminants discharged to urban rivers. In these countries, targeted pollution mitigation requires an understanding of where, how and when contaminants enter water bodies. Here we report on contamination of the Ciliwung River, a dynamic, tropical system flowing through the Jakarta metropolitan area (Indonesia). We measured a set of isotopic, chemical and microbial tracers in representative water and contamination sources, as well as longitudinally within the river, to assess the spatial and temporal variations in contaminant levels in and pathways to the river. In the dry season, we observed a tight coupling between locally recharged groundwater sources and the river, whereas in the wet season, one single water source originating from the fractured headwaters predominantly contributed to river flow. Yet, the flushing of upstream waters in the wet season did not always lead to the dilution of contaminants downstream. We delineated several contamination hotspots along the river, particularly active during the wet season due to higher hydrological connectivity between sources and the river. These hotspots may originate from septic tank leakage, as supported by metal ratios and dominant microbial communities, although we could not rule out other potential sources such as urban runoff or sediment resuspension. Bayesian source tracking on the whole microbial community proved useful in outlining processes that conventional tracers did not capture, such as the occurrence of a localised domestic contamination in the upper catchment, and the inflow of agricultural runoff all along the river profile during the wet season. Our study emphasises the role of rivers as biogeochemical reactors that constantly process and transform contaminants and microbial communities. We also demonstrate the value of using isotopic, chemical and microbial tools together to trace the movement of water and contaminants through urban rivers.",
    keywords = "16S rRNA, Bacterial community, Heavy metals, Riverine processes, Sediment, Weathering",
    author = "Cl{\'e}ment Duvert and Priadi, {Cindy R.} and Rose, {Alea M.} and Ayik Abdillah and Marthanty, {Dwinanti R.} and Gibb, {Karen S.} and Mirjam Kaestli",
    year = "2019",
    month = "9",
    day = "10",
    doi = "10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.05.189",
    language = "English",
    volume = "682",
    pages = "382--393",
    journal = "Science of the Total Environment",
    issn = "0048-9697",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "September",

    }

    Sources and drivers of contamination along an urban tropical river (Ciliwung, Indonesia) : Insights from microbial DNA, isotopes and water chemistry. / Duvert, Clément; Priadi, Cindy R.; Rose, Alea M.; Abdillah, Ayik; Marthanty, Dwinanti R.; Gibb, Karen S.; Kaestli, Mirjam.

    In: Science of the Total Environment, Vol. 682, No. September, 10.09.2019, p. 382-393.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Sources and drivers of contamination along an urban tropical river (Ciliwung, Indonesia)

    T2 - Insights from microbial DNA, isotopes and water chemistry

    AU - Duvert, Clément

    AU - Priadi, Cindy R.

    AU - Rose, Alea M.

    AU - Abdillah, Ayik

    AU - Marthanty, Dwinanti R.

    AU - Gibb, Karen S.

    AU - Kaestli, Mirjam

    PY - 2019/9/10

    Y1 - 2019/9/10

    N2 - Wastewater treatment infrastructure is lacking in many developing countries, often resulting in high loads of contaminants discharged to urban rivers. In these countries, targeted pollution mitigation requires an understanding of where, how and when contaminants enter water bodies. Here we report on contamination of the Ciliwung River, a dynamic, tropical system flowing through the Jakarta metropolitan area (Indonesia). We measured a set of isotopic, chemical and microbial tracers in representative water and contamination sources, as well as longitudinally within the river, to assess the spatial and temporal variations in contaminant levels in and pathways to the river. In the dry season, we observed a tight coupling between locally recharged groundwater sources and the river, whereas in the wet season, one single water source originating from the fractured headwaters predominantly contributed to river flow. Yet, the flushing of upstream waters in the wet season did not always lead to the dilution of contaminants downstream. We delineated several contamination hotspots along the river, particularly active during the wet season due to higher hydrological connectivity between sources and the river. These hotspots may originate from septic tank leakage, as supported by metal ratios and dominant microbial communities, although we could not rule out other potential sources such as urban runoff or sediment resuspension. Bayesian source tracking on the whole microbial community proved useful in outlining processes that conventional tracers did not capture, such as the occurrence of a localised domestic contamination in the upper catchment, and the inflow of agricultural runoff all along the river profile during the wet season. Our study emphasises the role of rivers as biogeochemical reactors that constantly process and transform contaminants and microbial communities. We also demonstrate the value of using isotopic, chemical and microbial tools together to trace the movement of water and contaminants through urban rivers.

    AB - Wastewater treatment infrastructure is lacking in many developing countries, often resulting in high loads of contaminants discharged to urban rivers. In these countries, targeted pollution mitigation requires an understanding of where, how and when contaminants enter water bodies. Here we report on contamination of the Ciliwung River, a dynamic, tropical system flowing through the Jakarta metropolitan area (Indonesia). We measured a set of isotopic, chemical and microbial tracers in representative water and contamination sources, as well as longitudinally within the river, to assess the spatial and temporal variations in contaminant levels in and pathways to the river. In the dry season, we observed a tight coupling between locally recharged groundwater sources and the river, whereas in the wet season, one single water source originating from the fractured headwaters predominantly contributed to river flow. Yet, the flushing of upstream waters in the wet season did not always lead to the dilution of contaminants downstream. We delineated several contamination hotspots along the river, particularly active during the wet season due to higher hydrological connectivity between sources and the river. These hotspots may originate from septic tank leakage, as supported by metal ratios and dominant microbial communities, although we could not rule out other potential sources such as urban runoff or sediment resuspension. Bayesian source tracking on the whole microbial community proved useful in outlining processes that conventional tracers did not capture, such as the occurrence of a localised domestic contamination in the upper catchment, and the inflow of agricultural runoff all along the river profile during the wet season. Our study emphasises the role of rivers as biogeochemical reactors that constantly process and transform contaminants and microbial communities. We also demonstrate the value of using isotopic, chemical and microbial tools together to trace the movement of water and contaminants through urban rivers.

    KW - 16S rRNA

    KW - Bacterial community

    KW - Heavy metals

    KW - Riverine processes

    KW - Sediment

    KW - Weathering

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065890330&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.05.189

    DO - 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.05.189

    M3 - Article

    VL - 682

    SP - 382

    EP - 393

    JO - Science of the Total Environment

    JF - Science of the Total Environment

    SN - 0048-9697

    IS - September

    ER -